USDA Proposes New Horse Protection Act Rule:
Why the Broader Horse Industry Should Pay Attention
The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) has released a new proposed rule (APHIS-2026-0067) implementing the Horse Protection Act (HPA), the federal law intended to prevent soring. Although the proposal is primarily aimed at addressing longstanding concerns within the Tennessee Walking Horse and Racking Horse industries, it raises questions that extend beyond those sectors.
The proposal follows USDA’s withdrawal of a much broader 2024 rule that generated significant concern throughout the horse industry. Many stakeholders, including AHC, believed the earlier proposal expanded federal oversight into breeds and disciplines that historically had not been the focus of Horse Protection Act enforcement. While USDA describes the new proposal as more targeted, important questions remain about its scope and future implementation.
Why Do We Need To Pay Attention?
APHIS has repeatedly stated that its enforcement focus remains on Tennessee Walking Horses and Racking Horses. During a stakeholder call held just prior to the proposal’s release, agency officials emphasized that they do not intend to direct enforcement efforts toward sectors that have not historically faced Horse Protection Act enforcement.
While those assurances are encouraging, many stakeholders have noted that enforcement priorities can change over time and that agency statements do not carry the same weight as regulatory language. As a result, many organizations are looking for greater certainty within the rule itself rather than relying solely on current agency intent.
This concern was at the heart of the industry’s opposition to the withdrawn 2024 rule. The debate was never about whether soring should be prohibited. Rather, it was about ensuring regulations remain appropriately focused on documented problems without unnecessarily expanding federal oversight into other segments of the horse industry.
What Could This Mean for the Broader Horse Industry?
Although APHIS consistently identifies Tennessee Walking Horses and Racking Horses as its primary focus, several provisions of the proposal are written broadly and apply to “any horse” participating in covered horse shows, exhibitions, sales, or auctions.
As a result, owners, trainers, exhibitors, event managers, and breed organizations across a wide range of disciplines are reviewing the proposal to determine whether it provides sufficient assurance that federal oversight will remain appropriately tailored and limited.
The proposal would also preserve APHIS inspection authority at covered events and retain the Designated Qualified Person (DQP) program, one of the most closely watched aspects of the rulemaking.
The DQP Question
One of the proposal’s most significant policy decisions is APHIS’s choice to retain the DQP system rather than replace it with a fully-federalized inspection program.
For years, the DQP model has faced criticism from USDA’s Office of Inspector General, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, the American Association of Equine Practitioners, and others who questioned whether an industry-administered inspection system can effectively police the industry it regulates.
Instead of replacing the system, APHIS is proposing to strengthen it through additional federal oversight, training requirements, audits, testing standards, reporting obligations, and conflict-of-interest protections.
AHC and others question whether additional oversight is sufficient enough to address longstanding concerns about the effectiveness and independence of the current model.
AHC Requests Additional Time for Review
Given the proposal’s complexity and potential impact, AHC has formally requested an extension of the public comment period.
The current proposal provides only 30 days for public review. AHC has requested a minimum 60-day comment period, with a strong preference for 90 days. At more than 140 pages, the proposal raises complex legal, regulatory, and operational questions that warrant careful review by horse owners, breed organizations, competition groups, veterinarians, and equine businesses.
AHC Is Working With Industry Partners
AHC is coordinating with stakeholders from across the horse industry on both the comment period extension request and the development of substantive comments on the proposed rule.
As this review continues, AHC and its partners are evaluating potential impacts, identifying areas that require clarification, and developing recommendations for USDA’s consideration.
Members can expect additional updates and analysis through AHC member alerts and advocacy communications as the rulemaking process moves forward.
The Bottom Line
There is broad agreement across the horse industry that soring should be eliminated and that effective enforcement of the Horse Protection Act is important.
The key questions raised by this proposal are whether it provides certainty for the broader horse industry, whether it appropriately balances industry involvement with federal oversight, and whether the revised DQP framework will address longstanding concerns without creating unintended consequences.
AHC will remain actively engaged throughout the rulemaking process and will continue to keep members informed as additional developments emerge.
